Streaming Device Showdown: Best TVs, Sticks, and Boxes After Netflix Killed Casting

Hook: Your streaming setup just got complicated — here’s how to fix it

If you’ve felt the ground shift under your thumbs since Netflix quietly pulled broad phone-to-TV casting in late 2025, you’re not alone. Suddenly the simple workflow of opening Netflix on your phone and sending it to a TV is a hit-or-miss gamble. For cinephiles who want cinematic picture and sound, predictable playback control, and a lean, uncluttered setup, this change exposed a bigger truth: casting as a universal control layer is gone, and native playback on devices (or robust second‑screen alternatives) matters more than ever.

What changed — and why it matters in 2026

Netflix’s decision to limit casting in early 2026 accelerated a transition already underway: streaming services are moving to a native-app-first model on TVs and boxes. That means the easiest way to guarantee full-quality playback and remote control is often to run the app directly on the device attached to your TV, not to treat your phone as the remote. The shift has immediate consequences:

• Mobile casting reliability has dropped for many Netflix users — older Chromecast dongles and a very small subset of devices are exceptions.
• Devices with complete native app support (and up-to-date codecs like AV1 hardware decoding) are now the safest bets for uninterrupted, high-quality streaming.
• Second-screen control survives, but only in ecosystems that actively support it — notably Apple AirPlay, updated Roku/TV mobile apps, and vendor-specific “pairing” approaches.

How cinephiles should think about devices in 2026

Stop thinking about “casting” and start thinking in three layers: native app playback (the app running on the TV/device), second-screen control (your phone/tablet as a remote or queue manager), and audio/video fidelity (bitrate, codecs, HDR, Dolby formats). The ideal device nails all three.

Priority checklist for a lean cinephile setup

• Native app parity: Ensure the device has a full Netflix app (and other services you use) updated for 2026 playback features.
• Second-screen control options: AirPlay 2, device mobile apps, or reliable networked remote protocols.
• Codec and HDR support: AV1 hardware decoding, Dolby Vision, HDR10+/HDR10, and proper HDR tone-mapping.
• Audio passthrough: eARC/ARC with bitstream for Dolby Atmos and DTS:X to your AVR or soundbar.
• Firmware update track record: Devices from manufacturers that still push timely updates win.

Device and ecosystem comparison — who still lets you control playback easily?

Below I compare the most relevant ecosystems in 2026 with an eye toward cinephile needs and second-screen control. Each section includes practical recommendations for a lean setup.

Apple ecosystem — AirPlay + Apple TV 4K (best second‑screen experience for iPhone/iPad users)

Why it’s strong: AirPlay 2 remains the most seamless second-screen system for iOS users. Apple TV 4K offers first-class native apps, reliable updates, and excellent AV feature support (Dolby Vision, Dolby Atmos). For many cinephiles the Apple TV remains the easiest way to guarantee Netflix native playback and phone/tablet control.

• Second-screen: AirPlay for direct streaming from iPhone/iPad; remote via Apple TV Remote in Control Center; Apple Watch controls for playback.
• AV fidelity: Typically great HDR and Atmos support; works well with AV receivers over eARC.
• Practical tip: Use the Apple TV app’s “Up Next” and Siri for quick searching across multiple services when you want to skip juggling apps.

Roku — the pragmatic choice (best cross-platform stability)

Why it’s strong: Roku’s strength is parity and simplicity. In 2026, Roku models continue to offer broad native app support, a dependable mobile app that functions as a remote and private-listening endpoint, and AirPlay 2 support on newer models for iOS users.

• Second-screen: Roku mobile app remote and voice control; AirPlay 2 supported on many models.
• AV fidelity: Good HDR support on higher-end Roku players; check model specs for Dolby Vision.
• Practical tip: For a lean setup, pair a Roku Ultra with an AVR; enable bitstream audio output to your receiver to preserve Atmos.

Amazon Fire TV — affordable and Alexa‑centric

Why it’s strong: Fire TV sticks and boxes are cheap and widely available, and Amazon’s app ecosystem includes native Netflix apps. The Fire TV mobile app offers a remote, but second-screen control is not as universally seamless as AirPlay. In exchange you get good value and frequent sales.

• Second-screen: Fire TV mobile app remote; Alexa voice control; limited AirPlay support via third-party bridging apps.
• AV fidelity: Selected Fire TV devices support Dolby Vision and Atmos; verify the specific model.
• Practical tip: If you use Prime extensively, Fire TV can be the single lean device for most streaming; add a small HDMI audio extractor or AVR for higher-end audio.

Google TV / Chromecast family — reimagined after casting changes

Why it’s strong: Google TV devices (Chromecast with Google TV and many Sony TVs running Google TV) prioritize the native app experience and search-first UX. After Netflix’s casting change, Google’s devices that include remotes became the more reliable path to Netflix playback. Legacy casting-only Chromecasts without remotes are an odd exception: some older dongles remain supported, but the safe bet is a device with a remote and a local Netflix app.

• Second-screen: Google Home and Google TV mobile app can act as remotes; AirPlay support is limited but growing across partner TVs.
• AV fidelity: Google TV devices increasingly support AV1 hardware decoding (important for YouTube/Max/other services adopting AV1) and HDR formats on higher-end models.
• Practical tip: If you want Android flexibility and sideloading for niche codecs, choose a full Android TV / Google TV box (e.g., Sony’s models or the NVIDIA Shield) rather than a casting-only dongle.

NVIDIA Shield & Android TV boxes — best for tech‑savvy cinephiles

Why it’s strong: The Shield and high-end Android TV boxes remain the most configurable—excellent for local media servers (Plex/Jellyfin), codec support, and wired Ethernet. If you keep a ripped Blu-ray collection and want direct-play fidelity, these boxes are invaluable.

• Second-screen: Android TV apps offer remote control and casting-like features for supported apps; Shield excels at local playback control via Plex/Jellyfin.
• AV fidelity: Strong support for passthrough, Dolby Vision on select models, and better tunability for advanced playback options.
• Practical tip: Pair Shield with a Plex server using Direct Play to avoid transcoding and preserve the original bitrate and formats.

Smart TVs (Samsung Tizen, LG webOS, Hisense, Vizio) — the convenient but mixed bag

Why they’re mixed: Modern smart TVs increasingly ship with mature native Netflix apps, but manufacturers vary in update cadence and codec support. Samsung and LG usually offer good native apps and excellent panel technology, but for cinephiles the app’s playback quality and audio passthrough options must be checked per model.

• Second-screen: Many TVs offer mobile app remotes and limited AirPlay or Chromecast support, but behavior varies in 2026.
• AV fidelity: Best-in-class panels (OLED, QD-OLED) live here — but ensure your TV’s OS doesn’t downconvert or limit bitrates for certain services.
• Practical tip: If you prefer a single “smart TV” device, verify Netflix’s native app shows 4K/HDR playback on that exact model before committing.

Game consoles — PS5 and Xbox Series X | S

Why they’re useful: Consoles have robust Netflix and streaming apps and excellent HDMI audio support. They’re less nimble as secondary controllers but are a solid option when you want dependable native playback in a living‑room that doubles as a play space.

• Second-screen: Console companion apps allow basic remote control and keyboard input.
• AV fidelity: Strong audio passthrough options and reliable 4K HDR output.
• Practical tip: Use consoles if you need a single-box solution that also handles gaming; otherwise choose a leaner streaming stick for less power draw and faster boot.

Actionable setups: lean configurations for different cinephile priorities

Below are three practical, lean setups you can assemble in 30–60 minutes. Each balances second-screen control and native app playback while prioritizing film-quality output.

Setup A — The Minimalist Cinephile (clean, budget-conscious)

• Device: Roku Streaming Stick 4K or Fire TV Stick 4K Max (choose based on which app ecosystem you prefer).
• Audio path: TV HDMI out to soundbar with eARC or directly to a compact AVR supporting eARC.
• Why it works: Both Roku and Fire TV provide native apps, simple remote control, and reliable firmware. The mobile app acts as a quick second-screen remote when needed.
• Pro tip: Turn off TV post-processing in picture settings to preserve film grain and black levels.

Setup B — The AV-First Cinephile (best picture and sound)

• Device: Apple TV 4K (2023/2024 model) or NVIDIA Shield TV Pro depending on whether you prefer AirPlay or local media server strength.
• Audio path: HDMI from device to AVR supporting eARC/HDR passthrough (Denon/Marantz or equivalent).
• Why it works: Apple TV offers the cleanest second-screen control for iPhone users; Shield optimizes for high-bitrate local files and codec flexibility.
• Pro tip: Use bitstream audio for Atmos to let the AVR decode, and set video output to match your TV’s native color space.

Setup C — The Mobile-First, Lean Rack (for people who control everything from a phone)

• Device: Apple TV 4K for iOS households; Roku or Google TV box for Android households.
• Audio path: Soundbar with eARC to reduce box count; enable passthrough for Atmos when available.
• Why it works: Prioritizes phone/tablet as the remote controller with a device that supports reliable mobile pairing (AirPlay for iOS, Roku/Google app for Android).
• Pro tip: Keep your phone/tablet on the same Wi‑Fi network and enable static IP for the streaming device to keep pairing stable.

Advanced tips — keep your lean setup future-ready

These are small config choices that preserve quality and control as streaming evolves in 2026.

• Prefer devices with AV1 hardware decoding: AV1 is becoming the standard for high-quality, bandwidth-efficient streams in 2025–26. Devices without hardware AV1 will struggle to keep up.
• Enable eARC on TV/AVR: Use eARC to pass Dolby Atmos and high-bitrate audio to an AVR or compatible soundbar. Disable TV audio processing to avoid upmixing that ruins the original soundtrack.
• Test native vs. casted quality: When in doubt, compare the same title’s bitrate and HDR treatment on a native app vs. a casted session. Native apps usually win for maximum bitrate and stability post-Netflix changes.
• Use local servers for maximum fidelity: Plex/Jellyfin with Direct Play lets you preserve original bitrates and bypass streaming platform compression for your personal library.
• Lock down firmware updates: Opt-in for automatic updates on devices known for fast security/feature patches (Apple, Roku, NVIDIA). Keep a weekly firmware check for Smart TVs.

Second‑screen survival recipes — actionable fixes for common problems

If casting is flaky or Netflix won’t accept your phone as a remote, try these straightforward fixes:

1. Make sure both the TV/device and phone are on the same Wi‑Fi network and that guest/ap isolation is off.
2. Update app and device firmware — many issues are fixed in late‑2025 and early‑2026 patches.
3. If Netflix won’t cast, open the Netflix app on the TV/device directly. Pair your phone using the device’s on-screen pairing codes when supported.
4. Use AirPlay (iOS) or the device’s mobile app (Roku, Fire TV) as a fallback remote instead of casting content.
5. For local libraries, use Plex/Jellyfin native apps on the device so the phone only serves as a remote/controller, not the stream source.

Industry trends shaping the next wave of devices (late 2025 → 2026)

Expect a few ongoing shifts to shape what you buy next:

• Native-app-first streaming: Platforms will continue to favor app-level features (watch-party, optimized HDR/Audio) on TV-side apps rather than phone-controlled casting.
• Wider AV1 adoption: More services and devices will use AV1 by default in 2026; choose hardware that decodes AV1 to future-proof your setup.
• Better eARC handling and home theater integration: As Atmos adoption rises, expect cleaner passthrough workflows and smarter TV/AVR negotiation.
• Privacy and ad concerns: Buyers are choosing platforms (and devices) that minimize tracking and intrusive recommendations. That can influence whether you select Amazon Fire TV or a more privacy-focused option like Apple TV or Shield plus a privacy-minded router setup.

"Casting is dead. Long live casting!" — A reminder that although the old, universal casting model has been pared back, practical second-screen control still exists in ecosystems that invest in it.

Final verdict — the best streaming devices after Netflix’s casting change

Short version: For cinephiles building a lean, future-ready setup in 2026, favor devices with robust native apps, solid AV feature support, and reliable phone/tablet control options.

• Best overall (iOS households): Apple TV 4K — AirPlay, polished apps, and consistent updates.
• Best cross-platform and value: Roku Ultra / Streaming Stick 4K — stable native apps and excellent mobile remote.
• Best for local media and flexibility: NVIDIA Shield TV Pro or high-end Android TV boxes — unrivaled for direct-play and codec support.
• Best budget sticks: Fire TV Stick 4K Max — cheap, widely supported, and solid native playback.

Actionable takeaways — what to do this weekend

• Check the native Netflix app on your current TV/device for 4K/HDR playback; if it’s missing, plan a replacement before your next big movie night.
• If you rely on phone control, pick AirPlay (iOS) or Roku/Google TV devices that explicitly advertise mobile app control and pairing.
• Set up eARC with your AVR or soundbar and verify Dolby Atmos passthrough with a known Atmos title.
• If you keep a local library, configure Plex/Jellyfin to Direct Play and test across your candidate devices for the best fidelity.

Call to action

If you want a tailored lean setup checklist, tell me your living-room priorities (panel type, AVR or soundbar, which subscriptions you use) in the comments or sign up for our Streaming Setup Guide. We’ll map the exact device and cable list you need to get cinematic playback, zero guesswork, and a phone that behaves like the perfect remote again.

Related Reading

• You Met Me at a Very Chinese Time: What the Meme Really Says About American Nostalgia
• How Google's Gmail Decision Affects University Admissions and Recruiters
• Where to Find the Best Post-Holiday Tech Deals for Car Owners (Head Units, Dashcams, Power Banks)
• Case Study: How a Multi‑Site Physiotherapy Chain Cut Onboarding Time by 40% with Flowcharts
• How to Avoid Beauty Gadget Hype at Trade Shows: A Shopper’s Checklist